Guide 06
Putting the dividend back, or taking it home
Reinvestment is the decision to use a cash dividend to buy more of the investment, or more of something else. It is not magic, and it is not mandatory. If the reason you own the shares is to pay the gas bill, taking the cash is the design, not a failure of discipline. If the reason is to leave the holding alone for fifteen years, cash that sits in a brokerage account at no yield is a leak.
An arithmetic sketch, with the assumptions stapled to it
Start with £10,000. Assume a dividend yield of 4% paid at the end of each year, reinvested in full, and a share price that also rises 3% a year. Assume no fees, no tax, no cuts and no gaps. None of those assumptions will survive contact with a real account. They exist so you can see the shape of compounding, not so you can expect the destination.
| After | Value if dividends are spent and price rises 3% | Value if dividends are reinvested and price rises 3% | Value if dividends are reinvested and price never rises |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | £11,593 | £14,104 | £12,167 |
| 10 years | £13,439 | £19,893 | £14,802 |
| 15 years | £15,580 | £28,058 | £18,009 |
The first column is £10,000 grown at 3% with the 4% cash removed each year, so the capital is not reduced by the dividend but also does not compound it. The second column grows the whole pot at about 7.12% because a 3% price rise and a 4% dividend reinvested at the new price compound together: each year the factor is 1.03 × 1.04. The third column reinvests a 4% dividend and assumes the price is flat, so the pot compounds at 4%. Round pounds. If the dividend is cut to zero in year six, every column is wrong. If a 0.45% fee is deducted, every column is optimistic. If basic-rate dividend tax of 10.75% is paid outside an ISA on the dividend above the allowance, the cash available to reinvest is smaller and the gap versus an ISA widens as the pot grows past £500 of dividends.
Registrar plans
Some companies offer a dividend reinvestment plan through their registrar. You elect once, and each dividend buys more shares, sometimes including a fraction, sometimes rounded, sometimes with a small dealing charge or a stamp duty charge. The terms sit in a booklet. Turning the plan off is a form, not a mood. If the shares are held in a nominee at your broker, the registrar plan may not be available, because the registrar cannot see your name. The broker’s own “reinvest dividends” toggle is a different switch.
Buying by hand
The other method is to let the cash gather and place a trade when it is large enough that commission does not eat it. A £12.50 dealing charge on a £60 dividend is an ugly ratio. The same charge on a £1,500 quarterly sweep is dull, which is what you want. Fractional shares, where the broker allows them, shrink this problem. Not every UK broker offers fractions, and a fraction may not carry the same shareholder rights as a whole share.
Tax changes the amount you can put back
Inside an ISA, a dividend can be reinvested without UK dividend tax reducing it. Outside, the tax is still due even if you immediately buy more shares. You have not “rolled it up” for tax purposes by refusing to withdraw it to your bank. The allowance and the rates in the tax guide are what shrink the reinvestment. Paying that tax from salary, rather than from the dividend, is possible if you have the cash, and it is still a cost of owning the unsheltered shares.
When taking the income is the grown-up choice
A household that has stopped earning a salary and has planned to spend natural income should not be scolded by a compounding table. The table assumes you do not need the money. Sequence matters in the other direction too: if you reinvest through a high market and then need to sell after a fall, the elegant fifteen-year number never arrived in your life. Write down which job the dividend has this year. Jobs can change. The label is what stops the default setting on a website from making the decision for you.